End of an Era: Connecticut Muffin Bids Farewell to Clinton Hill After 22 Years

As noted in an exclusive article from NYC Newswire, after over twenty years of service in Clinton Hill, Connecticut Muffin will be closing its doors on Saturday, November 29, 2025. Situated on the bustling corner of Myrtle Avenue and Clinton Avenue, the café has been a community landmark since launching in 2003. However, a sharp increase in rent has forced the business to close.

Rent Hike Prompts Closure

Staff members confided to NYC Newswire that the landlord intends to raise the rent by an extra $4,000 per month, making the lease unaffordable. The café’s exit will remove a beloved local gathering place, known for its consistent service and welcoming environment.

Connecticut Muffin on Myrtle Ave Clinton Hill Brooklyn Final Day Counter by NYC Newswire

Morning Routine Staple for Many

Connecticut Muffin has long provided Clinton Hill with coffee, lattes, muffins, and pastries. Pratt students, area families, and longtime locals have counted on the café as a welcoming space, whether starting the day or relaxing with a snack. Its reliability made it a cherished business within the community.

Staff Transferring to Brooklyn Locations

Although the Clinton Hill shop is shuttering, customers will still find many familiar faces at other Connecticut Muffin Brooklyn locations:

• Park Slope: 423 7th Avenue, Brooklyn, NY

• Ditmas Park: 1106 Cortelyou Road, Brooklyn, NY

Those who wish to stay in touch with their favorite employees can visit them at these addresses.

Connecticut Muffin on Myrtle Ave Clinton Hill Brooklyn Final Day Interior by NYC Newswire

Neighbors React with Sadness

The announcement has left locals disappointed. One loyal customer told NYC Newswire:

“I’m really going to miss this place. It’s my go-to spot at least 4 days per week. There are other coffee shops around but none like Connecticut Muffin. The staff has always been pleasant and the products have always been consistent. It’s a shame that we continue to lose great neighborhood spots because of high rents.”

Farewell to a Community Landmark

A steady stream of regulars is expected on November 29 for one last visit. Connecticut Muffin’s closure signals the end of an era in Clinton Hill and highlights concerns about the vulnerability of small businesses to skyrocketing commercial rents.

Subscribe to the ClintonHill.com Newsletter for regular updates on local news, development, restaurants, retail changes, events, and more.